She Brains - HeBrains

Bigger - Stronger - Faster...arethere really any differencesbetween female brains and male brains? Differences between the brains ofmen and women have generated considerable scientific and public interest.If there are differences in the way that men and women behave, then it isreasonable to suppose that their brains have something to do thesebehavioral differences. Just what are these differences and where in thebrain might these differences be located?

For hundreds of years,scientistshave searched fordifferences between the brains of men and women. Early research showingthat male brains were larger than female brains was used to "prove" thatmale brains were superior to female brains. Of course, this "proof" isNOT so simple and straight forward as youwill see. Nevertheless, even today, there is a lot of controversy aboutthe differences in the brains of men and women. Not only from ananatomical point of view, but also from a functional point of view - inother words, just what do the differences in the brains mean?

Hormones that are present during a baby's development will affect thebrain and determine whether the brain will be female or male. Studies thathave looked at differences in the brains of males and females have focusedon:

  1. Total Brain Size
  2. The Corpus Callosum
  3. The Hypothalamus

Differences in Total Brain Size?

Almost all studiesshow that at birth, a boy's brain is bigger than a girl's brain. Atbirth, the average brain of boys is between 12-20% larger than that ofgirls. The head circumference of boys is also larger (2%) than that ofgirls. However, when the size of the brain is compared to body weight atthis age, there is NO difference betweenboys and girls. So, a girl baby and a boy baby who weigh the same willhave similar brain sizes.

In adults, the averagebrain weightin men is about 11-12% MORE than theaverage brain weight in women. Men's heads are also about2% bigger than women's. Remember though, men on average weigh morethan women and that absolute brainsize may not be the best measure of intelligence.Many behavioral differences have been reported for men and women. Forexample, it has been said that women are better in certain languageabilities and men are better in certain spatial abilities. Many studieshave tried to find differences in the right and left cerebral hemispheresto suggest that male and female brains are different. However, few ofthese experiments have found meaningful differences between men and women.If fact, there are many similarities between the cerebralhemispheres of men and women.

Brain Weights

(Data from Geigy Scientific Tables, 7th edition,edited by K. Diem and C. Lenter, 1970)

Differences in the CorpusCallosum?

mri The major pathway that connects the rightand leftcerebral hemispheres is called the corpus callosum.(The corpus callosum is the fiber tract made up of 200-250 million axons that is cut in split brainpatients.) Many recent claims have been made that the corpus callosumis bigger and more developed in women than in men. These claims have evenbeen reported in the popular media (Time Magazine, Jan. 20, 1992,pp. 36-42; Newsweek Magazine, March 27, 1995, pp. 51). However,recent studies have told a different story. Using new magnetic resonanceimaging methods, researchers have found no differences in thesize of the corpus callosum in men and women. Further research thatcompares the size of the corpus callosum size in men and women is needed.

Differences in the Hypothalamus?

The hypothalamus is one area of the brain with well-documented differencesbetween men and women. Two areas of the hypothalamus, the preoptic areaand the suprachiasmatic nucleus, have clear differences in female andmale brains.

Preoptic Area of the Hypothalamus
This area of thehypothalamus is involved in mating behavior.In males of several species including humans, the preoptic area is greaterin volume, in cross-sectional area and in the number of cells. In men,this area is about 2.2 times larger than in women and contains 2 timesmore cells. Apparently, the difference in this area is only apparentafter a person is 4 years old. At 4 years of age, there is a decrease inthe number of cells in this nucleus in girls. The exactfunction of this nucleus in behavior is not fully known.

Suprachiasmatic Nucleus of theHypothalamus
This area of thehypothalamus is involved with circadian rhythms and reproduction cycles. The only difference between women and men inthis area is one of shape: in males, this nucleus is shapedlike a sphere; in females it is more elongated. However, the number of cells and volume of this nucleus are not differentin men and women. It is possible that the shape of thesuprachiasmatic nucleus influences the connections that thisarea makes with other areas of the brain, especially the other areas of the hypothalamus.

Women and Men - Boys andGirls

The behavioral and neurologicaldifferences between men and women require further study. Perhaps newstudies will find neuroanatomical differences that explain some of thecomplex differences between male and female behavior. However, from areview of the current scientific evidence, it appears that differences inmany cognitive behaviors (for example, memory) are related more to individual differences between people than to whetherpeople are female or male.

----------------------------------------------------------

More on possible differences between male and female brains:

----------------------------------------------------------

BACK TO:Exploring theNervous SystemTable ofContents

[email]
Send E-mail

Fill out survey

Get Newsletter

Search Pages

Take Notes